Antony’s Struggles at Manchester United and Success at Real Betis: What’s Behind the Transformation?

Antony, the Brazilian winger, made a high-profile move from Ajax to Manchester United in 2022 for a hefty €100 million. However, his time at Old Trafford was marred by underwhelming performances, leading many to question whether the transfer was a costly mistake. In stark contrast, Antony’s loan spell at Spanish club Real Betis in 2024 has seen a remarkable turnaround, with the player showcasing his true potential. This article explores Antony’s struggles at Manchester United, his revival at Betis, and the factors behind his transformation.

Antony’s Disappointing Stint at Manchester United

Underperformance at Manchester United
When Antony first arrived at Manchester United, expectations were high. After all, the winger had impressed at Ajax under Erik ten Hag, United's then-new manager. Yet, in the 2024-25 season, he played just 14 matches and scored a single goal. Over the course of two and a half seasons at the club, Antony made 96 appearances, scoring 12 goals and providing 5 assists — statistics that were far from the impact United had hoped for from a player of his price tag.

Playing Style Misalignment
One of the key reasons for Antony’s struggles was his playing style, which didn’t align with Manchester United’s needs. His physicality, or rather the lack of it, was a major concern. Antony often struggled in one-on-one duels and had difficulty coping with the Premier League's intense pace and physical demands. Furthermore, his tendency to play a selfish style of football, often looking to cut inside rather than create space for others, made him an inconsistent figure in United's attack. Even with ten Hag, his former Ajax coach, at the helm, Antony found it hard to secure a starting spot. By the first half of the 2024 season, he had only been named in the starting lineup three times — a clear sign of his struggles to adapt to the Premier League.

Antony’s Breakout at Real Betis

Immediate Impact at Betis
Antony’s loan move to Real Betis in January 2024 marked the start of a new chapter. Within just 11 days of joining the Spanish side, Antony proved his worth by scoring a stunning goal against Gent in the UEFA Conference League, which helped Betis secure a 3-0 win. His excellent form continued, as he scored two goals and assisted one in his first three matches, quickly shedding the “flop” label he had accumulated at Manchester United.

High-Profile Performances
Antony’s performances at Betis were nothing short of spectacular. In his debut match for the club against Athletic Bilbao, he earned the Man of the Match (MVP) award after contributing to a 2-2 draw. In another standout performance, he scored his first goal for Betis in a 3-2 loss to Celta Vigo, once again taking home the MVP honors. In the Conference League, he delivered yet another goal in Betis’ 3-0 victory over Gent, solidifying his status as one of the club’s key players. His contributions, both on and off the ball, were undeniable, and it became clear that he had found his rhythm in La Liga.

Why Did Antony Thrive at Real Betis?

Tactical Fit
A major factor in Antony’s success at Betis was the tactical system employed by his new manager, Manuel Pellegrini. While Antony struggled to adapt to Manchester United's three-center-back formation under ten Hag, Betis' 4-2-3-1 setup suited his strengths. Playing as a right-winger in a more traditional attacking role, Antony was able to cut inside onto his stronger left foot and unleash shots or create opportunities for others — a style he thrived in at Ajax. The more expansive and less physical nature of La Liga further allowed him to utilize his technical abilities without being overly hindered by defensive pressure.

Change in Environment and Mindset
At Manchester United, Antony faced immense pressure due to his hefty price tag and the expectations of a demanding fanbase. The constant scrutiny took a toll on his mental state, leading to inconsistent performances. Moving to Real Betis, however, gave him a fresh start in a more relaxed environment. With fewer expectations and a manager who trusted his abilities, Antony gained confidence. The more laid-back atmosphere of La Liga allowed him to play with freedom, without the fear of constant judgment. This shift in environment played a crucial role in his resurgence.

Individual Characteristics Suited to La Liga
Antony’s playing style, with its focus on close control, dribbling, and technical flair, is more suited to the slower, less physically demanding pace of La Liga. While the Premier League's high intensity may have exposed some of his physical limitations, the Spanish league’s more strategic and technical style of play allowed Antony to shine. His exceptional left foot, capable of curling in precise shots, was a weapon he could unleash more effectively in the relaxed tempo of Spanish football.

Conclusion: A Story of Transformation

Antony’s time at Manchester United was largely defined by unmet expectations and an inability to adapt to the demands of the Premier League. However, his loan spell at Real Betis has shown what he is truly capable of when placed in a more suitable environment and system. By thriving under Pellegrini’s 4-2-3-1 formation, playing with greater freedom, and adjusting to a less physically demanding league, Antony has reestablished himself as a key player.

Whether Antony can maintain this level of form upon his return to Manchester United or whether he will look to extend his stay at Betis remains to be seen. However, his journey offers valuable lessons on the importance of tactical fit, mental well-being, and the impact of a supportive environment on a player's performance.